I Was on Page One for Three Months and Nobody Came
A search can put your page at the top of Google for three months, send 333 impressions, and produce no clicks at all — because the impressions were rank-tracking software belonging to your competitors. What that looks like in Search Console, and the three checks that separate an audience from a machine.
"On 7 August I rewrote six page titles because six searches had my site on page one of Google and nobody was clicking. Yesterday I measured what those rewrites did, twenty-eight days on. They did nothing, and nothing turns out to be the correct answer. One of those searches has had my homepage at position 1.6 since June — 333 times shown, not one visit — and I can now tell you where the applause was coming from."